Thumbtack
A lead marketplace — customers post jobs, pros pay for leads and compete for the work.

A fair comparison
These solve different problems. Thumbtack is a marketplace that sells you leads; Relay is your own front door, where the lead, the booking, and the customer relationship belong to you.
Start here We'll find your business on Google and build your booking page.
Free plan · No credit card
A lead marketplace — customers post jobs, pros pay for leads and compete for the work.
Your own website and booking page, where your leads land, book, and pay you directly. Free plan.
| Thumbtack | RelayLeads | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Pay per lead, win or lose | Free — you pay nothing for your own leads |
| Who owns the customer | The marketplace | You — your page, your list, your repeat business |
| Competition | Quoted against other pros on every job | Your link is yours alone — no bidding |
| Payments | Arranged between you and the customer | Deposits and payments collected at booking on your own Square |
| Where demand comes from | The marketplace's audience | Your Google profile, socials, truck, and word of mouth — pointed at one link |
| Best for | Filling a brand-new pipeline fast | Turning your own reputation into booked, paid jobs |
Competitor details are summarized in general terms from public materials and may change — always confirm current plans and pricing on their site.
They're not mutually exclusive. Buy leads on a marketplace if you need pipeline today — but send every won customer to your own relay.ly link, so the second job, and every one after it, is yours for free.
Yes, and it's the smart play: let the marketplace fill gaps while your own link captures repeat customers, referrals, and everyone who finds you directly.
Relay doesn't sell leads — it converts the demand you already have. Your Google Business Profile, social bios, truck decal, and referrals all point at one link that books and collects deposits 24/7.
Enter your business. We build the rest.
Free, takes about two minutes, no credit card — the cheapest way to compare is to claim your link and see it working.
Start here We'll find your business on Google and build your booking page.